So, I am probably the last person in this country to write my opinion on the "acquittal heard 'round the world" but there has been a development in the story. Early this morning, Casey Anthony was released from jail, given $537 from her jail account, and sent on her way to live a free life. There have been endless Facebook and blog posts about people angry at her, the jurors, and the legal system in general. One of her lawyers recently confirmed that they had received a number of threats including an email with a modified image of Miss Anthony with a bullet in her head.
By the way, the picture to the right is of a mother partying while her daughter lies dead and decomposing in the woods.
This type of desire for vigilante justice is as old and the court system. If the court fails to prove somebody guilty beyond a reasonable doubt and the public disagrees, this type of thing happens. Does anybody remember OJ Simpson? Yes, we have all heard a million comparisons, but this case seems a little different in my mind. First and foremost, there is no racial tension to deal with in this situation. She's white and her child was white. Secondly, there was no dramatic chase that lead many to imply OJ's guilt as he was running (if you call that running) from police. For Casey Anthony, it was just lies about her missing daughter and a non-existent nanny that she claimed abducted little Calyee. Either way, the justice system seems to have failed to provide justice for the victims of both crimes.
So, what are we to do about it? We can complain, sure. We can make new laws that, if they had been in place, would have kept Casey in jail for a few more years, but it won't fix the problem. The problem is that we have an imperfect system. Everything is governed by money and lawyers. The video footage of Casey Anthony's defense team celebrating with drinks and dancing to their victory is disturbing. Sure they won, but who in their right mind can believe that Casey Anthony is completely innocent. The verdict said it best; the jury found the defendant NOT guilty. So, why should she be allowed to go free you may ask? Well, that same justice system that allowed the defense team party like it was 1999 also allows guilty people to go free if enough evidence can't be found. Guilty beyond a reasonable doubt is something that is very hard to prove.
Now, I don't know all the specifics on the Brian David Mitchell trial or why it took so long (I refer anybody wondering to ask Ben Wood as he covered the sentencing process) but the man was guilty as sin. He was discovered WITH the girl he abducted, she testified in court of what he did, and yet there was still the possibility of him NOT going to jail for life because the court couldn't determine if he was sane enough to stand trial. What does that say about the legal system? People that are insane can't be held accountable for what they do? The defense in the Casey Anthony trial claimed that she had been abused by her father while she was young and used that to justify her not reporting the death of hear daughter. What? First let me say that I have never had to deal with anything as heinous as abuse. I have no idea what any of those poor souls who experience that have to go through and I feel eternally sorry for them. However, sane or insane, you should have to pay the price for your crime just like anybody else. I could go on and on about how much I hate the legal system and how I firmly believe it is largely to blame for the current financial crisis and any issues with healthcare. If people weren't allowed to sue surgeons for being human and making mistakes, or sue doctors for not being absolutely perfect, healthcare and insurance would not cost near as much. You know what, I will go as far as saying that any problem in this world can be blamed squarely on lawyers, lobbyists, and politicians. There you have it. Now, back to the subject of this rant.
Casey Anthony should be allowed to go free because that is how the justice system works. We can't make an exception just because somebody managed to hide something so well that investigators couldn't find enough evidence to allow a jury in any good conscience to hand out a guilty verdict. I feel very bad for the jurors. Some of them have reached out claiming that they felt sick to their stomach the day of the verdict. They may believe she is guilty, but all they did was their civic duty in weighing the evidence and making the hardest decision of their lives. As for Casey Anthony, she may not have been proven guilty of murder, but she has proven herself guilty of being a bad mother and overall disgraceful human being. Who knows what demons she has been fighting all her life, but I am sure she will have several to fight for the rest of this life and well into the next. If she is guilty, she will pay for it eventually. If she does happen to be innocent to some degree, she will have to answer for lying in a life and death situation. Either way, the future looks pretty bleak for her. Who would hire somebody like that? Who would want a person like that living in their neighborhood? I have no idea, but the whole story just leaves a bitter taste in my mouth. I hope you have all enjoyed my little rant on the current legal system and I would love any and all commentary on the issue. I suppose what I am asking is: does anybody disagree with me?
Much better. While I agree that the legal system is imperfect and whole-heartedly disagree with what I take as an critique of the philosophy of innocent until proven guilty.
ReplyDeleteOur CRIMINAL legal system (again, I couldn't agree more that civil lawsuit have reached epidemic proportions in our country) was created as INTENTIONALLY imperfect. Our founding fathers though it was better to allow the occasional guilty person go free in order to secure the freedom of the innocent. By shifting the burden of proof on the state we, the people, are protected.
Casey Anthony did bad things, and she was convicted of some of them (lying to prosecutors, for example) but she is innocent of murder until proven guilty. The same system that keeps me, a law obiding citizen out of jail, found her "not guilty" of murder and as a society we need to accept that and let her live her life. I find the public's response to this (death threats and the like) considerably more appalling than the alleged failure of the court. As far as I am concerned, Casey Anthony is innocent of murder, just like me, you, and most of the people I know and while the legal system may be abused, the underlying principals it is based upon are just, and admirable.
BTW, thanks for the shout out.